Don't defend them in public
Your employee may be completely in the right. A reply that says so still reads as the business telling a customer they are wrong, in front of everyone who reads your reviews later. Future customers picture themselves as the reviewer, not as your staff. Have the real conversation with your employee in private, where it belongs.
Don't repeat the employee's name
The reviewer used the name once. If your reply uses it again, it now appears twice, once in your own words, right under the complaint. Say "our team" or "the person who helped you" instead. It answers the review just as well and does not tie a staff member to the complaint any more than it already is.
A reply that works
- Thank them for taking the time to write, even if it stings.
- Apologize for the experience in one plain sentence. You are not agreeing with every word; you are sorry the visit went that way.
- Say you have shared it with the team, but only if you really have. Do not promise discipline, retraining or firing in public.
- Sign as the business, never as the employee, and keep it to three or four sentences.
Google says replying to reviews shows you value customer feedback [1], and replies are reviewed against Google's content policies before they appear [2]. Google does not say replies directly raise your ranking.
Example replies (fictional)
Example review (fictional) · ★★
"Our server Jake forgot half our order and acted annoyed every time we asked for something."
Example reply (fictional)
Thank you for telling us, and we're sorry your visit went this way. Missing half the order and feeling like a bother is not how anyone should be served here. We've shared this with the team. - Example Diner
Example review (fictional) · ★
"The receptionist, Maria, was rude and would not let me reschedule."
Example reply (fictional)
We're sorry the front desk visit left you feeling this way. Being treated with patience is the least you should expect when plans change, and we've passed your review on to the team. - Example Salon
Example review (fictional) · ★★★★★
"Tasha was amazing with our nervous dog. We will be back!"
Example reply (fictional)
Thank you! We'll make sure Tasha sees this. Nervous pups are her specialty, and we're glad yours went home happy. - Example Grooming
Notice the last one: on a happy review, using the name is a gift. The rule is only about complaints.
When the review accuses someone of something serious
Harassment, violence, discrimination or someone being drunk at work is not a reply-template situation. Read it yourself, find out what happened, keep any public reply short and serious, and do not argue facts or admit fault in public. Answered holds reviews like these for the owner to read and approve before anything posts.
What if the review is from a former employee or a competitor?
Google's policies don't allow reviews written from a conflict of interest, such as by a former employee or a competitor, or reviews that aren't based on a real experience [3]. You can report those from your Business Profile, and Google decides whether they come down [4]. In the meantime, a short, calm reply that says you can't find the visit is what a reader should see.
See it on your own reviews. Open our free demo with an example review filled in, or paste one of yours, and see the reply we'd write. Or start a 7-day free trial and have every Google review answered in your voice. Then from $49 a month; card required, cancel anytime.
Sources
- Google Business Profile Help, "Tips to improve your local ranking on Google"
- Google Business Profile Help, "Manage customer reviews"
- Google, "Prohibited and restricted content (Maps user-generated content policy)"
- Google Business Profile Help, "Report inappropriate reviews on your Business Profile"
Example reviews and replies on this page are made up for illustration. Not legal advice. Updated 2026-10-12.
More guides
- How to respond to negative Google reviews (with examples)
- How to respond to positive Google reviews (with examples)
- How to respond to a 3-star review (with examples)
- How restaurants should respond to bad reviews
- How dentists should respond to online reviews (and protect patient privacy)
- How auto repair shops should respond to bad reviews
- How contractors should respond to bad reviews
- Google review reply templates you can adapt (by situation)
- How to report a fake Google review (and what to do while you wait)
- What Google says about replying to reviews (and what it does not)
- How to choose a Google review reply service: a buyer checklist
Replies for your kind of business: see every industry we serve, or compare Answered plans and pricing.